Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Give the Sign and Swing Away

Reading Saussure last week was a little bit intimidating, but I will try to make some sense out of it. When he says, "in language there are only differences without positive terms," he is saying that meaning only comes from within the linguistic system. For example, our meaning of Night is only comprehensible because we understand Day and vice versa. Therefore he says "the idea or phonic substance that a sign contains is of less importance than the other signs that surround it." Meaning that when we look at signifier and signified separately, their meaning is "differential and negative," but when looked at together, we are able to get a positive and total meaning. So, we can not understand the meaning of a word unless we look at it in the context of the linguistic system.

Post Structuralism works to challenge these ideas. For this theory it is not so simple to say that combining signifier and signified can give us a total meaning; they do not have a stable relationship. In class we discussed the idea that the signified keeps slipping farther and farther away, and in its place we continue to get more signifiers. Therefore we can truly never get at the meaning of something because the meaning keeps getting deferred. I want to try and give and example of this... bare with me.


Let's use 'baseball' as the signifier. You have the image in your head, and you know what it sounds like. So what is the signified? Is it the actual ball? Or do you take the meaning of 'baseball' to be the sport itself. If so, you start to see other signifiers right? Like players, teams and rules. With each one of these signifiers, the meaning of 'baseball' gets father and farther away from you. All these other and sounds and images expand and defer the meaning and we are unable to get a true and stable meaning of the word.


Hopefully, I didn't confuse you... because I am still kind of confused! Haha.



Ciao until next time!

3 comments:

Hiravda said...

When I first looked at the quotes to choose from I had no idea what it meant. Your explanation in the first paragraph cleared everything up. It also helped me understand a few things that became a little confusing in class the other day.

Mae Dupname said...

In class, when we were talking about post-structuralism and how meanings can be deferred I wasn't sure how that was possible. Reading your example really cleared things up. Baseball has so many meanings that we can never totally define it, which makes it unstable. Thanks for your post, it really helped me a lot!

pelipuff said...

I have to admit with the others that after sitting in class, I had no idea of what to comment on or had a true sense of what they were trying to get at. However, your analogy with baseball helped clear things up - mainly because it is a sport that I can closely relate to, but also one that fits perfectly within the comment. Baseball can have many meanings, and it only up to us to truly define and bring meaning to the terms.